Comparative remarks: Protoconch. The protoconch is typically rapanine; it is multispiral with 3+ whorls (exact figure cannot be given due to imperfect preservation of protoconch specimen) as opposed to the typical paucispiral protoconch in ocenebrines of 1.5 whorls; and the outward-flaring lip and sinusigeral notch are indicative of a planktotrophic larval stage, found in all rapanines and absent in ocenebrines. The Acanthais protoconch is similar to that of Stramomta in both overall shape and sculptural pattern.
Shell Morphology. Acanthais bears a strong superficial resemblance to three ocenebrine genera, Acanthina Fischer von Waldheim, 1807 (type species: A. monodon (Pallas, 1774), southern South America); Acanthinucella Cooke, 1918 (type species: A. punctulata (Sowerby, 1835), California); and Spinucella Vermeij, 1993 (type species: S. tetragona (Sowerby, 1825), Pliocene, North Sea Basin). All four genera possess a labral spine and strong spiral cords. Acanthais differs from members of the Ocenebrinae by columellar, apertural, and sculptural characters.
Like many Rapaninae, Acanthais has sculpture on the columella. In Acanthaisy there is a central fold. This fold is much weaker than the central fold of Cymia Morch, 1860 (type species: C. tecta (Wood, 1828), tropical eastern Pacific). The latter genus differs widely from Acanthais in its lirate aperture, fine spiral ribs, adapical apertura! notch, and strong peripheral tubercles. Ocenebrines have a smooth columella. Some rapinines also have a smooth columella. These include Concholepas Lamarck, 1801 (type species: C. concholepas (Bruguiere, 1789), western South America); Rapana Schumacher, 1817 (type species: R. bezoar (Linnaeus, 1758), Indo-Pacific); Ecphora Conrad, 1843 (type species: E. quadricostata (Say, 1824), Pliocene of Virginia); and limpetlike morphs of Plicopurpura Cossmann, 1903 (type species: P. columellaris (Lamarck, 1816), tropical eastern Pacific). These taxa are low-spired to limpetlike, and have a sculptural pattern different from that of Acanthais and related genera.
In Acanthais. there is a parietal rib that terminates as a distinct knob at the apical end of the aperture. This feature is absent in most Ocenebrinae, including Acanthina and Spinucella. Some species of Acanthinucella and many populations of Nucella emarginata (Deshayes, 1839) from California possess a parietal tubercle, but this feature is discrete and is not a spiral parietal rib as it is in Acanthais and most other Rapaninae. A similar parietal rib occurs in members of Muricinae.
The five-rib pattern of major spiral cords on the body-whorl sets Acanthais apart from Ocenebrinae but links it to many members of the Rapaninae. The adapical cord, or subsutural ridge, lies just below the suture and periodically forms apically directed extensions that produce weak knobs. At the outer lip, the most recently formed of these extensions produces a gutterlike extension with the opposing terminus of the parietal rib. The subsutural cord and corresponding posterior apertural gutter are found in nearly all Rapaninae but are lacking in Acanthina, Acanthinucella, Spinucella, and other Ocenebrinae. Most ocenebrines have seven or more primary spiral cords. Members of the Acanthinucella lugubris (Sowerby, 1821) group from northwest Mexico (see Wu, 1985) have only four primary spiral cords, the two apical ones bearing nodes and the two basal cords being broadly rounded and set close together. Recent specimens of the Nucella emarginata species complex have five major cords, but there is no subsutural cord as in Rapaninae.
Among rapanine genera, Acanthais bears a strong superficial resemblance to Stramonita Schumacher, 1817 (type species: S. haemastoma (Linnaeus, 1767), Mediterranean and West Africa). In both genera, cords 2 and 3 on the body whorl (counting from the suture) are adorned with a row of equally prominent nodes. The primary cords of Stramonita, however, are narrow and angular, whereas those of Acanthais are low, broad, and round-topped. Moreover, the two genera differ in secondary spiral sculpture and in the way that the primary cords are reduced in many populations. In Acanthais, cord 5 (the most basal one) is rarely expressed, so that the primary sculpture appears to consist of three closely spaced cords on the central portion of the body whorl and a very weak noded subsutural cord. The entire shell surface is overlain by extremely fine spiral threads. In populations of Stramonita in which the primary spiral cords are reduced, the primary cords are of the same size as, and are difficult to distinguish from, the relatively coarse secondary cords or riblets. This is especially so in western Atlantic populations of S. haemastoma (belonging to the subspecies floridana Conrad, 1837, and canaliculata Gray, 1839), in the eastern Pacific S. biserialis (Blainville, 1832; Figure 1D-F), and in the Peruvian S. delessertiana (Orbigny, 1941). These typical species of Stramonita also differ from Acanthais by the presence of riblets (lirae) on the inner side of the outer lip. Lirae are absent in Acanthais. Moreover, typical species of Stramonita lack the central columellar fold of Acanthais, and also lack a labral spine.
The tropical eastern Pacific genus Neorapana Cooke, 1918 (type species: N. muricata (Broderip, 1832)) resembles Acanthais in possessing a short labral spine in a position just basal to cord 5. In shell characters, Neorapana differs from Acanthais by lacking the central columellar fold, by having the inner side of the outer lip Urate rather than smooth, and by possessing an umbilical slit.
Several Indo-West-Pacific rapanines are also superficially similar to Acanthais. Thais aculeata (Deshayes & Milne Edwards, 1844) is the type of Thalessa H. & A. Adams, 1853, but was assigned to Stramonita by Fujioka (1985) on the basis of radular characters and to Mancinella Link, 1807 (type species: M. alouina (Roding, 1798), tropical Indo-Pacific) by Trondle & Houart (1992). This species and its relatives have a weak to obsolete central col¬umellar fold and, like Acanthais, a nonlirate outer lip bearing denticles on its inner side. However, whereas it is the fifth (most basal) primary spiral cord that is often missing in Acanthais, the fourth cord is usually weakest in the T aculeata group. Strong erect spines adorn all five cords or all but the fourth cord in Thalessa. The coarse secondary spiral sculpture of Thalessa resembles that of Stramonita rather than the fine threads of Mancinella or Acanthais. It may be that Thalessa is close to Stramonita, but further anatomical study is needed to clarify the placement of this group.
Finally, Acanthais shares many features with Thais Roding, 1798 (type species: T. nodosa (Linnaeus, 1758), tropical West Africa). Species of Thais resemble Acanthais in having exceedingly fine secondary spiral sculpture and in lacking lirae on the inner side of the outer lip, but they lack a central columellar fold and a labral spine. In T. nodosa, all five primary spiral cords are usually well developed and bear nodes or tubercles; but in the closely similar T. meretricula Roding, 1798, from the central Atlantic islands, the shell surface is covered by very fine spiral sculpture and lacks distinct primary cords.